Page 3 of 3

Re: [July 7 2011]- Immortality

PostPosted: Wed Jul 20, 2011 11:48 am
by Jesse M.
Kimra wrote:You may think you aren't finding Pratchett the enemy, but each time you have mentioned the situation you have been certain to mention his 'theft' (however inadvertently). Just observing.

Sure, but that's just because that was my original claim ("I think he stole this joke from Woody Allen") and I was defending it against someone who was posting specifically to say I was wrong.
Kimra wrote:However what I was implying, more than to say that your brief search was incorrect, was that perhaps with greater research (not limited to the internet) you might find that Woody Allen is also a thief.

I'm sure that's quite possible, but you're reading something into my post that isn't there if you think I am "for" Woody Allen and "against" Pratchett or something. All I'm doing is defending the original claim that he stole this one joke from Allen, which as I said is really not something I'm condemning him for or even saying he necessarily did it consciously (that's why I linked to the example of George Harrison apparently stealing a melody without realizing he was doing it). I think a lot of comedians do modified versions of jokes they've heard elsewhere, it's not a big deal unless it's done really frequently and without putting their own spin on the jokes.

Re: [July 7 2011]- Immortality

PostPosted: Wed Jul 20, 2011 11:51 pm
by Apocalyptus
I think Kimra's point is that it's not really within our power to know whether you are right, or they both came up with the joke independently. Which is possible, it's not really a huge logical leap to come up with something like that.

Re: [July 7 2011]- Immortality

PostPosted: Thu Jul 21, 2011 2:39 am
by GUTCHUCKER
It is within my power to know when I am right. This is because I am always right, and never wrong like you pathetic mortals are.
In any case, nobody can write anything completely original, so I can't see why there would be any point in discussing it. This is like pulling an individual piece of grass out of a lawn and saying you saw a similar blade in Terry Pratchett's book and he totally copied it from someone else guys, this is serious business.
Good artists create, great artists steal!

Re: [July 7 2011]- Immortality

PostPosted: Thu Jul 21, 2011 8:37 am
by Kimra
Good artists create, great artists are inspired!

Re: [July 7 2011]- Immortality

PostPosted: Thu Jul 21, 2011 10:34 am
by Gangler
An artist who relies on inspiration is slave to a fickle mistress.

Re: [July 7 2011]- Immortality

PostPosted: Thu Jul 21, 2011 10:51 am
by Edminster
An artist that does not suggest adding fries to your order is a sellout.