[2011-Jul-26] Wildly Naive

Blame Quintushalls for this.

Moderators: NeatNit, Kimra

ghoest

[2011-Jul-26] Wildly Naive

Post by ghoest »

http://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?db=comics&id=2318

Is he saying in the votey that socialism and anarchy are individually wildly naive or that conflating the two indicates a wildly naive worldview?

User avatar
Edminster
Tested positive for Space-AIDS
Posts: 8835
Joined: Fri Sep 09, 2005 9:53 pm
Location: Internet
Contact:

Re: July 26: Wildly Naive

Post by Edminster »

No. The "wildly naive" descriptor is applied to the boy, not the politics.
ol qwerty bastard wrote:bitcoin is backed by math, and math is intrinsically perfect and logically consistent always

gödel stop spreading fud

unapologetic anarchist

Re: July 26: Wildly Naive

Post by unapologetic anarchist »

Actually, the descriptor applies to the boy's "political views". Those views, as indicated by his shirt, are an opposition to GMOs, a fondness for socialism and a fondness for anarchism.

I agree that it is naive to be opposed to GMOs based on some 'natural is good and GMOs aren't natural' fallacy, but there are real reasons to oppose GMOs as they lead to a vast reduction in genetic diversity among food crops, among other issues. http://ngm.nationalgeographic.com/2011/ ... ty-graphic

I don't see it as naive to be in favour of both socialism and anarchism. As an anarchist, I see both anarchism and socialism as likely to produce better outcomes than the current capitalist system. Depending on who you ask, anarchism may actually be described as a sub-species of socialism, especially 'social anarchism' or 'anarcho-communism' (check wikipedia for more info).

And the reference to naiveté immediately reminds me of a great comic by Matt Bors: http://www.mattbors.com/archives/781.html
Who is really the naive one, Zach?

I don't want to get into a big debate about political theory, but I would just ask those who instinctively call radicals, revolutionaries, anarchists and socialists "naive" to actually read some well-regarded political theorists who hold those ideologies rather than basing their views on things that their Che t-shirt wearing nephew spouted off about during the last Thanksgiving dinner.

csmk

Re: July 26: Wildly Naive

Post by csmk »

This comic is old-school. Just like the early ones. I love it!

matrixbandit

Re: July 26: Wildly Naive

Post by matrixbandit »

How long do you suppose until they start selling the t-shirt from the votey in the SMBC store? Anyone want to take bets? :D

User avatar
Edminster
Tested positive for Space-AIDS
Posts: 8835
Joined: Fri Sep 09, 2005 9:53 pm
Location: Internet
Contact:

Re: July 26: Wildly Naive

Post by Edminster »

unapologetic anarchist wrote:Actually, the descriptor applies to the boy's "political views".
wrong. if i hold an apple and believe that apple is the saviour of mankind, it is not the apple that is naive.

ideas cannot be naive, they simply point out naivete.
ol qwerty bastard wrote:bitcoin is backed by math, and math is intrinsically perfect and logically consistent always

gödel stop spreading fud

User avatar
Gangler
watashi wa kawaii desu ne ^o^;
Posts: 906
Joined: Tue Jul 13, 2010 11:42 pm

Re: July 26: Wildly Naive

Post by Gangler »

csmk wrote:This comic is old-school. Just like the early ones. I love it!
Edminster wrote:
unapologetic anarchist wrote:Actually, the descriptor applies to the boy's "political views".
wrong. if i hold an apple and believe that apple is the saviour of mankind, it is not the apple that is naive.

ideas cannot be naive, they simply point out naivete.
These two things.

I'd also point out that feeling the need to wear that shirt when meeting your girlfriend's parents is an indicator of naivete on a level entirely separate from any of his political ideals. He surely must have had a shirt better suited for that occasion in his possession somewhere.
Paranoid? Probably. But just because you're paranoid doesn't mean that there isn't an invisible demon
about to eat your face.

User avatar
Lethal Interjection
Death by Elocution
Posts: 8051
Joined: Wed Oct 12, 2005 2:17 pm
Location: Behind your ear. It's magic!
Contact:

Re: July 26: Wildly Naive

Post by Lethal Interjection »

Precisely.
The anarchy and socialism don't have to be naive, but the kid's perspective on them might be.

Where's the beef?

Re: July 26: Wildly Naive

Post by Where's the beef? »

Edminster wrote:
unapologetic anarchist wrote:Actually, the descriptor applies to the boy's "political views".
wrong. if i hold an apple and believe that apple is the saviour of mankind, it is not the apple that is naive.

ideas cannot be naive, they simply point out naivete.
If you really think that apple is the saviour of mankind then you are certainly naive.

User avatar
Edminster
Tested positive for Space-AIDS
Posts: 8835
Joined: Fri Sep 09, 2005 9:53 pm
Location: Internet
Contact:

Re: July 26: Wildly Naive

Post by Edminster »

Where's the beef? wrote:
Edminster wrote:
unapologetic anarchist wrote:Actually, the descriptor applies to the boy's "political views".
wrong. if i hold an apple and believe that apple is the saviour of mankind, it is not the apple that is naive.

ideas cannot be naive, they simply point out naivete.
If you really think that apple is the saviour of mankind then you are certainly naive.
Exactly!
ol qwerty bastard wrote:bitcoin is backed by math, and math is intrinsically perfect and logically consistent always

gödel stop spreading fud

NR22
Posts: 6
Joined: Tue Jul 19, 2011 8:43 am

Re: July 26: Wildly Naive

Post by NR22 »

Believing Socialism doesn't make you naive.
Not questioning your government does.

User avatar
Lethal Interjection
Death by Elocution
Posts: 8051
Joined: Wed Oct 12, 2005 2:17 pm
Location: Behind your ear. It's magic!
Contact:

Re: July 26: Wildly Naive

Post by Lethal Interjection »

NR22 wrote:Believing Socialism doesn't make you naive.
Not questioning your government does.
Wrong.
It could just mean you are apathetic.

User avatar
DonRetrasado
los más retrasadadados
Posts: 2845
Joined: Tue Aug 31, 2010 6:27 am
Location: ¡Canadia!

Re: July 26: Wildly Naive

Post by DonRetrasado »

I would've thought that socialism and anarchism are quite mutually exclusive, but apparently they're not*.

Anyway the joke is definitely about people who blindly embrace counter-culture movements and expose their own ignorance. Like wearing a Che Guevara T-Shirt without the least familiarity with the Cuban Revolution.

*I, of course, did not actually read the article.

EDIT: Come to think of it, the Livestrong wristband phenomenon pretty adequately mirrors Che Guevara's popularity in terms of "fashion articles that people do not understand the significance of". Although Livestrong supports a charity instead of a violent radical, so that's a plus.
Astrogirl wrote:Lethal, nobody wants to know about your herpes.
Lethal Interjection wrote:That's good to know. I can avoid a few awkward phone calls now.

User avatar
GUTCHUCKER
Gotchucker's less handsome twin
Posts: 2126
Joined: Wed Dec 01, 2010 2:26 am
Location: Paradise City?

Re: July 26: Wildly Naive

Post by GUTCHUCKER »

they lead to a vast reduction in genetic diversity among food crops, among other issues
Umm, that's a good thing. We want them as is.
...Also, HOW? Which food crops? What other issues?
I am irritated.
Datanazush wrote:I ship Mohammed and Jehova.

Quintushalls
Posts: 120
Joined: Sat Sep 11, 2010 2:32 pm

Re: July 26: Wildly Naive

Post by Quintushalls »

As a male, if I tried threatening to do this, I would never get that video game.

Post Reply